Transcript for gr-l09

Hello everybody.0:08

This is later nine.0:12

We are remarkably enough and I0:13

cannot congratulate myself enough0:16

for this on time, which is very good.0:17

So we have a full 3 lectures to cover0:21

Part 4 which is back to the physics of GR.0:23

So the intense the intellectual payoff0:27

of the. Of the weeks up to now.0:31

Before we started on that, however.0:34

And according to supervisions,0:36

for historical reasons,0:40

the way that the general course had0:41

been covered by provisions has been0:43

different from the other courses.0:46

It's been a separate.0:47

You have supervision sessions rather0:50

than small groups of provisions, but.0:52

There's some flux in the way0:56

that these will be managed,0:58

and it has occurred to me that0:60

it might be useful to have it.1:02

Haven't previously done office hours,1:04

but either an office hour1:07

I could announce or else.1:10

As some others have done for the Honors1:13

courses bookable slots at a certain time.1:16

Does anyone have any feelings about this1:19

or any suggestions on this sort of topic?1:21

Is that a good idea that a bad idea?1:23

Of those two possible models,1:25

which one is is an obviously better one or?1:27

And. Yeah. OK. Business.1:31

And think otherwise.1:35

OK,1:38

the world is I'll I'll identify a1:38

suitable time and I don't really know1:40

your timetables are the afternoons out.1:43

Or other mornings out? Or is there a?1:47

Is there an obviously bad time to1:49

organise to just an officer? Anyone.1:52

I don't know your timetables.1:54

He's normally bad 10 to 1225 bad.2:00

OK, so if I said picked one o'clock one day,2:04

would that be a suitable sort of?2:09

Seems of notes OK I think.2:12

I think with that and sort that out.2:15

I think that is all.2:20

Are there any other questions or thoughts2:21

or anxieties to do with to do this that2:25

you have anxieties not to do this are?2:29

Excluded, OK and let's get going and I will.2:33

Before I I said part 4,2:38

but before I do that I will just2:39

mention a couple of things about2:42

the the the very end of part three.2:44

At the end we're racing for the,2:47

we're racing for the finish line as it were.2:49

And I I I, I I skipped through the bit on2:52

on Judy Deviation but there's a couple2:55

of things I do want to just mention.2:57

I won't work through the.2:59

The derivation of this or the corroboration,3:02

I'll ask you either to look at the3:05

notes or just take it and trust3:07

the point of duty deviation. Is.3:09

You might remember this picture3:12

from part one.3:15

We talked about the idea of of two things3:16

falling toward the center of the Earth.3:20

And because they are falling3:22

to the center of the earth.3:23

The heading toward the same point, and so.3:25

Although they are both in freefall.3:31

Each of the two observers in3:33

at either end of that well see,3:35

spaceship or whatever,3:37

we'll see the distance to the other3:38

one decrease at an increasing rate.3:41

They will be strictly in quote,3:44

accelerating toward each other in3:46

the specific sense that the second3:48

derivative of their separation3:50

will be nonzero.3:52

But they will not be accelerating.3:53

They will not be feeling any push3:55

if they were holding a Plumb Bob,3:57

but that wouldn't work.3:59

If you're holding some sort of4:00

accelerometer then they wouldn't4:02

detect anything as they were4:03

falling even though they were.4:05

There's a second derivative4:06

being non zero happening here,4:08

and that is because these two observers4:10

at either end of the spaceship or4:12

train carriage or they want to call4:14

it are both following geodesics.4:16

But those eugenics,4:18

the separation between those judaics,4:20

is changing as a function,4:22

as a quite complicated function of time.4:24

Because of the curvature of the4:26

space they're falling through.4:29

And we're going to talk about the4:31

relationship between curvature4:33

and gravity in a moment.4:34

But so just like jumping ahead of ourselves,4:35

the gravity that the this earth,4:38

this planet here. Has is for.4:41

Has the consequence that the4:47

space-time around it is curved in4:49

a way we'll learn about shortly.4:51

And so as those particles followed4:53

udic through it,4:55

those geodesics are straight lines in4:56

the space, but nonetheless curved.4:59

And so it's tidal effects like this,5:01

so-called tidal effects that are where and.5:03

The effects of gravity emerge.5:07

That's the picture I used to to5:12

set up the scamper through the5:14

last couple of pages of the note.5:17

The idea was, you recall,5:19

that there were multiple geodesics5:21

and were able to.5:23

This is another version of what we5:24

we what we stepped through fairly5:26

painfully in the last lecture of taking5:28

our vector for a walk around a closed path.5:31

In this case, the end result of that5:34

calculation was what would have been5:36

if we'd gone through step by step,5:38

would have been a calculation of.5:40

So much of this connecting vector at the top,5:41

which links points with equal5:44

parameter on the two geodesics.5:46

How much that changes and the answer.5:48

Jumping to the end.5:51

Was an expression like this,5:54

which I, I, I, I, I, I,5:56

I want to put up here so that I5:58

can refer to it later on when we6:01

when we discover when we can use6:03

that expression in a simple case.6:06

All it's saying is that the second6:09

derivative of the separation6:11

between the the the the the points6:13

on 2 neighbouring diuretics.6:16

Separation is a function of.6:18

The tangents to the duties.6:21

The separation itself,6:24

you know we're pointing here to here,6:25

and the Riemann tensor,6:28

so the so that the reason why6:29

this emerges naturally at the6:31

end of Part 3 is this is another6:32

case where the Riemann tensor is6:35

telling us what we want to know.6:37

About the shape of the space6:39

that we're going through,6:40

and this this time it's telling6:41

us stuff about the change6:43

that this connecting vector.6:45

This.6:49

This connecting vector here,6:52

how much that changes because of the6:53

curvature of the space that these6:55

duties are limited are limiting,6:57

so we'll see an example of that.6:59

Do you do you, do you geodesic7:02

deviation equation in not let7:05

me lecture after this one when7:07

you will be illuminated, I hope.7:09

Um. Key points. Any questions about that?7:15

So I I acknowledge I have7:23

effectively missed a bit out there7:25

because because the, the, the,7:27

the details are less important7:29

than the the the conclusion. So.7:31

Onward.7:38

So here we're back to physics. And.7:41

The two things I want to to to,7:47

to cover really in this part are first7:48

of all the equivalence principle.7:52

We touched on the equivalence principle in7:54

part one where I said that all free falling7:56

inertial frames are equivalent for the7:58

performance of all physical experiments.7:60

I think I actually said that in part one.8:01

If I if I didn't then prior to8:03

have done but you, you, you,8:05

you probably have seen that express8:07

somewhere and we find that the8:09

we're able now to put some.8:13

Mathematical flesh on the physical8:17

bones of that of that statement,8:19

that of the code principles.8:23

So we see where the as it were to8:24

use an overused image with with.8:27

This is where the rubber hits the road,8:29

as it were.8:30

And.8:32

My goal,8:35

the overall goal of this of of G18:35

is to get to the point where we8:38

can write down Einstein's equations8:39

and say that's the question,8:41

now go and answer it.8:43

But it's unfair to do that and not8:44

give our solution to IN equations8:47

and which describes our space-time8:50

of interest to us.8:52

And the one we, we, we,8:53

we,8:54

we look at is how we can recover8:55

nuisance theory of gravity from8:57

Einstein's theory so as the8:59

low energy and low speed.9:01

A bit of of of a against alien9:04

theory of gravity.9:08

Um.9:10

This is challenging, as I've said before,9:14

the point of the the objectives and the9:17

aims are closely linked to assessment,9:19

and this is challenging to assess because all9:21

the calculations are hideously long. So the.9:24

The assessment tends to be explained X.9:28

And, you know, show that you understand X.9:32

Basically, you persuade me that9:34

you have a clue type assessment9:36

rather than other things.9:38

But there are some simple dynamical9:40

calculations that you'll be able to9:43

do in certain contexts, which is.9:45

So there's a there's some simple calculations9:48

that are possible at the end of this.9:51

Um. OK.9:53

And you're in Newton's gravity.10:02

The source of gravity is matter.10:03

Is mass. The the the one of the10:06

terms in in in in the theory of.10:09

Law of universal gravitation or two10:13

of the terms are EMS, they're masses.10:15

So it's not surprise,10:16

no surprise that it's a mass that10:18

is that we have to to to think about10:19

and deal with in this context.10:21

However, let's be relativity.10:23

We can't talk about mass.10:24

The natural thing is talk about energy,10:25

momentum, the so it's not10:27

just the mass of something,10:29

but the energy the intimate10:30

has by virtue of his movement.10:31

So when something is moving rapidly.10:33

There's more energy momentum in10:36

it and so it gravitates more is10:38

what we're going to discover.10:41

We shouldn't be surprised at that,10:42

because if the energy momentum the, the,10:43

the, the, the, the momentum 4 vector,10:47

that is the key,10:50

the thing that's important in10:52

your study of relativity.10:53

And the way we we edge up.10:55

So we'll have to learn how to10:58

discover how to talk about the10:60

energy momentum in extended objects11:02

in a rustic relativistically11:05

satisfactory we we would do that,11:08

we would talk about dust.11:11

Which are beautiful you I want to just11:13

check I'm not missing something out here.11:15

I've I've I've notified of some remark11:17

I might want to make sure I made early.11:20

Ohh yeah.11:23

So just a minor thing.11:24

And I at this point up up up to11:25

this point we've been talking11:28

in about N dimensions.11:30

Of course,11:32

the reason we're talking11:33

interventions is to turn into n = 4,11:34

and so from now on we're talking about four11:36

dimensions with signature of of space-time,11:39

which in this case would be minus,11:41

plus, plus, plus.11:42

And I'm not going to use,11:44

I'm going for indexes.11:46

I'm going to switch to using11:47

Greek indexes for space-time11:49

Dimension 0123 and Latin ones11:51

for it's space only ones.11:53

That's just a slight notational11:55

tweak to fit in with the conventions.11:57

OK, so just. Matter is structured.12:01

There are all sorts of things that.12:06

That their whole disciplines12:10

devoted the structure of matter.12:12

That's complication.12:14

You can simplify that and talk about12:15

a perfect fluid which something with12:18

no viscosity but which has mass,12:21

mass, density and has pressure.12:24

You can simplify that so further.12:27

By talking of our of of of dust,12:30

which in this context is something which has.12:32

No internal structure,12:37

so there's no viscosity and it's all,12:39

there's a there's a frame12:42

in which it is at rest,12:44

so there's no pressure.12:45

So and the idea is a collection12:46

of dust particles.12:49

So this time we push has mass density.12:50

And nothing else.12:54

So let's imagine our box of this.12:57

There's a box of what?13:01

Plenty dot X dot Y dot Z. And.13:05

You can imagine it being moving at some13:08

constant speed with respect to it,13:12

or or we moving at some13:14

constant with respect to it.13:15

Now in that box will therefore13:20

length contract as your13:23

recollection or special activity13:25

will will immediately remind you.13:28

So I want to go through13:31

this in careful order.13:32

So the. And. The the volume.13:37

Ohh of in this other in other frame13:45

we just X prime delta Y prime delta13:49

Z primed with an extra factor of.13:53

The. Look at this update 10 no.13:57

With an X Factor of gamma.14:04

But that's the usual range factor.14:05

So the thing will length contract to the14:07

volume will go down by a factor of gamma,14:09

which means the density goes up by14:11

a factor that the number density14:13

goes up by a factor of gamma. Um.14:15

So if there is a, if we look at this14:21

and ask what is the flux of particles14:25

through the end wall of this with14:28

this thing is moving with respect to.14:30

I think the perspective is wrong in that.14:33

I think it's actually I need to14:36

redraw that I cannot tolerate14:38

perspective being wrong and then14:40

the the flux of particles through14:43

the the the end wall will be the.14:45

Volume of this X to the Y.14:49

Doctor Z.14:55

Divided by divided by.14:58

The flux is the number per15:00

unit area per unit time.15:03

Which they're going to end up with a flux.15:06

In the X direction. Being.15:10

And.15:20

Yeah, but I'm gonna let you15:26

jump to the end being gamma.15:28

In the X where N is the.15:30

The the number density in the rest frame.15:42

Turn off auto focus. OK.15:49

And. One can go through that in15:54

more step by step, I hope you you,15:58

you you agree that's that,16:01

that that that's reasonable.16:01

The point is that that that the16:02

number density is proportional to16:04

the velocity but with an extra16:06

factor of gamma because of the16:08

of the increase in the number16:10

of density because of the length16:11

contraction of the side of the box.16:13

And. That looks sort of familiar16:16

that that that looks like.16:20

N times.16:22

Gamma X and so we can jump to the16:26

conclusion that the there is a.16:30

Our flux vector here.16:33

Which is the number density times the.16:36

For velocity of the.16:41

Or the motion. So we're not just,16:46

it's not just general,16:48

not just specific.16:50

This is to the X direction.16:51

We'll jump to that conclusion.16:54

I mean, it will turn out to16:55

that as a sensible thing to do,16:56

as what I'm doing here is16:59

motivating this as an idea.17:01

So that's the.17:04

Flux factor.17:09

And the components of this.17:13

Are going, they're going to be MN.17:15

Yep, gamma, NVX, gamma,17:19

NVY, gamma, NV. Is it?17:23

How do we extract those components?17:29

Of the of the of the of the flux17:34

vector in exactly the the usual17:37

way by plugging a what one of17:39

the basis one forms into the.17:42

Into the. It's ****** factor.17:47

That's ****** vector. And.17:50

With the alpha basis one form17:55

plugged into it. And here as I say,17:58

I'm switching to using the the17:60

traditional thing of using Greek18:03

letters for the the 00 to 3 indexes,18:05

and I'll later use Latin letters for18:08

the spatial components, so that's.18:11

I'm just recapitulating stuff that18:14

you've you've seen before about18:16

the way we extract components or18:18

vector from the vector itself and18:20

and one of the basis one forms.18:22

Umm.18:28

So.18:35

We've here talked about the change in the.18:39

Numbered entity of the particles in the18:43

box and that number density has gone up18:45

because the size of the box has gone down.18:48

Usually retract. However,18:50

there's also a because these18:53

these these these dust particles18:55

in the box are moving at speed.18:57

The energy that they have.18:60

Is acquires another factor of gamma.19:02

So the energy of the particles19:06

in the box. Uh.19:09

Let's write down the, the, the, the.19:13

Energy ends up being gamma19:17

N the increase to the. Yeah.19:21

The increase in the number density.19:32

And each of these particles has a mass M.19:36

We inquired another gamma the energy in the.19:39

Of the particles of the box has acquired19:44

a gamma squared and that is a hint19:46

that we are not going to be able to19:48

describe this the energy of the particles19:50

in this box by a vector because.19:52

The. But by a rank one object,19:58

because the transformation of a rank20:01

one object from frame to frame would20:03

only pick up one factor of gamma,20:05

whereas it's clear we need two,20:07

so we're going to need a higher rank object.20:09

What do we have to to build20:12

that higher rank object?20:14

The things we have available are the20:15

momentum 4 vectors of the dust of the dust20:18

particles and the overall flux vector.20:21

So the the the metal dust particles is.20:24

It is telling us that in the in20:28

another frame the momentum of those20:31

dust particles would would change and20:33

we also are told that there is a an20:36

overall number density corresponding20:38

to the flux vector which will20:40

also change and so those are the20:42

two vectors we have to play with.20:44

And. So what we can do is.20:48

Guess and here are motivating20:53

again rather than deducing20:56

that there is our tensor.20:58

Which is the. The.21:00

Momentum for vector of the dust particles.21:06

Outer product with the. Sorry.21:11

The. Flux 4 vector of the particles21:16

as a whole. Which is going to be.21:21

M. You. Cross. And. You from above.21:26

Which is just. Role you.21:34

Because you were rules. You could.21:40

Amen. And I guess it's obvious M here21:42

the rest mass of the particles and N21:46

is the rest density of the particles.21:49

In, in, in the dust.21:52

And we can extract components of this.21:57

Kendra in the usual way by applying.22:03

Thesis.22:09

One forms to it. Which extracted which22:12

ended with being P. The. Xmu. Times.22:16

In.22:24

The. X. You.22:27

In again illustrating the way that the.22:32

The. We evaluate a natural product.22:37

By plugging the. In this case,22:40

one forms in turn into the two22:45

components of the outer product,22:48

and simply real number22:49

multiplying the results together.22:51

So that's that's that's an equivalent22:53

saying rather than an equal sign really.22:55

Did that. I don't see any looks22:60

of shock and horror. That's good.23:02

So the so the thing don't need to do again.23:04

Reassuring you that the sensible23:08

thing to do is to start looking at23:09

individual components of this object,23:11

which is the energy momentum tensor or23:13

the stress energy tensor of the dust.23:16

So this is the tensor which I assert23:19

is characterizing the energy and23:22

momentum of the dust as an assembly,23:24

which we are going to discover is the23:27

source of the gravitational field,23:30

gravitational field that the the23:32

the change to space-time around it.23:34

So let's look, for example, T00.23:36

There's usually a component. That um.23:41

P.23:48

DT times N. DT. And the.23:51

The same component of the Momentum23:58

4 vector is gamma M If you24:02

recall your special relativity.24:05

And the time component of24:07

the flux vector is gamma N.24:10

Which gives the.24:16

The. Term that, that,24:20

that that we sort of in a slightly24:21

hand WAVY way deduce earlier on.24:25

So that's reassuring.24:27

Um, the.24:30

T0Y and again this is me using24:35

Latin letters to indicate the24:39

space components of the tensor.24:41

That's so is 1 two or three?24:43

It's going to be P.24:47

ETN.24:51

The XI. Which will be gamma M.24:54

And gamma. And VI.24:60

And if we, you know that's different from.25:06

Here. And we look at that25:11

that has the dimensions of.25:15

Mass. Per unit area per unit time.25:22

So that is the. And match being in25:30

this context the same as energy.25:34

That's the energy flow per25:36

unit area per unit time.25:38

So that's the energy flow across.25:39

A surface of constant X per unit time.25:43

So that's the essentially the mass flow.25:49

That's been. The represented by the.25:54

The mass flow of the dust. And.25:59

That we can have a similar sort26:03

of thing argument for what TI0 is.26:06

That's the the spatial component of the26:09

momentum and the time component of the dust.26:11

And you can. It's supposed to reassure26:13

yourself that is the same as.26:16

At T0I you know there was this26:18

tensor is symmetric, turns out.26:20

And we can look at T IJ so the space26:24

space components of the tensor.26:30

Which will be equal to P. The XI.26:32

And. The X. G. Uh, which will be um?26:39

M. Gamma M Phi I times.26:49

Gamma26:56

NVJ which basically from the26:58

dimensions ends up being the.27:03

The. Flux the flux of momentum27:07

per unit area per unit time,27:10

which ends up being the force per unit area.27:12

And. There's typically argument argument27:15

here but but that that is picking up the,27:19

the, the, the, the,27:22

the the force that there would be on a27:24

wall of if if this body of flux but the27:27

this body of dust particles hit a wall.27:30

And that's that's. Force.27:33

Per unit. Area. Umm.27:38

So more more generally,27:46

what we're doing here is we're27:48

interpreting the various components of27:51

this tensor as the flux the way I put the.27:54

And the flux of the the the T Alpha beta is28:02

the flux of the alpha component of momentum,28:06

so energy or momentum across the beta.28:10

Our surface of constant beta the constant28:15

constant time I into the future or surface28:17

of constant of constant position, IE.28:21

The flow you know through the space.28:25

OK. I'm aware this is all28:32

slightly hand waving,28:36

but it's I as I say again,28:37

it's intended to motivate28:40

the the identification these28:41

things rather than reduce them.28:43

Now I said this was a perfect,28:49

this was just it had no pressure.28:52

If we relax that slightly28:56

and talk of a perfect fluid,28:57

a perfect fluid has no preferred28:59

direction so that the spatial part.29:01

So for the for the incrementum29:03

tensor describing that perfect fluid29:05

therefore cannot have any asymmetry,29:07

must be symmetrical.29:09

All directions in the all spatial directions.29:12

So that for a perfect fluid.29:15

And the.29:18

IG components the spatial.29:21

Spatial sector of the energy momentum29:25

tensor has to be proportional.29:28

To the to the identity29:31

matrix and by comparing what?29:34

What we've just seen is that29:42

it's plausible to identify the.29:45

The the spatial part of the29:48

energy momentum tensor as the.29:51

And at having the dimensions29:53

of pressure per unit. Time.29:56

Of of force per unit time,29:60

which is pressure.30:02

Then the spatial sector.30:04

Is it good to pee?30:07

Delta IG. And for a for dust put,30:11

the pressure is 0, therefore the spatial30:15

sector is going to be 0, so it's30:18

detrimental density is is very simple.30:20

Umm.30:24

Key now.30:28

In the.30:33

And.30:36

I. OK.30:40

Through for further. So yeah,30:46

like hand waving, pushback.30:50

I don't like this hand waving,30:51

but it's, it's, it's, it's sort of30:53

necessary to get to the the, the,30:55

the end point we can end up concluding.30:57

That.31:04

And.31:09

For a perfect fluid.31:13

That the form for the energy momentum31:18

tensor of our perfect fluid.31:20

So that's something which has no31:22

viscosity but does have pressure.31:25

Is ends up being a very simple form,31:27

which is just that you cross you.31:30

With terms involving the mass31:32

density in the restream. The.31:35

The pressure, so P here is pressure31:40

rather than momentum slightly31:43

unfortunately with an extra term31:45

which is the just the metric.31:47

And in the case of dust31:50

where the pressure is 0.31:53

That ends up being simply rule. And.31:56

000 for justice.32:11

In specifically the momentarily comoving.32:13

Reference frame MRF.32:17

So that's a long way of of saying32:20

that this energy maintains a32:23

clearly can be quite complicated.32:25

There's also things that could be in there.32:28

But the key things are the.32:32

Masters there.32:35

The actual objects there,32:37

which are expressed in things like32:39

the density, the mass density.32:41

And other motion,32:43

other sources of energy such as pressure.32:44

Which appear when in the case of a32:48

fluid but not in the case of dust and32:50

in the case of of the of the of dust,32:53

that energy metric tensor becomes,32:56

you know, reassuringly simple.32:58

It's it ends up with only one known 032:60

component in the the framework which33:05

is not moving and Lawrence transform33:07

Lorentz transform into other forms.33:11

Similarly that's.33:14

So this is a diagonal matrix there.33:16

OK,33:20

going on to slightly more substantive things.33:21

No.33:24

Section 412 is another way of arriving33:25

at that sort of sort of inclusion,33:28

which is is more satisfying in some33:32

respects and less satisfying others.33:35

This way of of getting33:38

to that conclusion does.33:40

It celebrates our return to physics33:42

here by by returning to slightly33:45

heuristic physical arguments.33:47

The other way of approaching this is to.33:49

Talk about the.33:53

The way in which you can describe33:57

volumes and describe volumes in33:59

a geometrical satisfactory way34:02

within relativity using one forms34:04

and two forms and similar things,34:06

because one forms as the the clues in34:09

the name at the bottom of a tree of34:11

more complicated geometrical objects.34:14

There's nothing else I want to say about34:15

that other alternative approach to this,34:17

but I but it doesn't have a34:19

dangerous because you might be34:21

interested and it's sort of relevant,34:22

but I'm not gonna say34:24

anything about it just now.34:26

And.34:28

OK.34:32

Would you were doing well?34:34

And now what we're going to do is34:37

to actually talk about the laws34:39

of physics in curved space-time.34:40

So this is really where34:41

we start to discover how.34:45

How all the maths we've done34:48

so far links to to physics,34:50

what we want to understand.34:53

Before we do that,34:55

we ought to make a detour back into34:56

into math by defining defining34:59

a couple of extra objects. Umm.35:01

But the they're fairly routine things,35:06

so they are just contractions35:08

of Riemann tensor,35:10

which turned to be of more ready35:11

significance. So #1 is. And.35:14

What? Is it the remote sensor?35:20

Alpha Beta you knew and contract35:25

it over the 1st. And 3rd indexes.35:28

Then we get an object with a.35:36

We've got a rank two object.35:43

With with the two unmatched indexes,35:46

which is called the Richie Tensor.35:48

So just a contraction of the of35:50

the Riemann tensor you plug in,35:54

plug plug two of the35:57

components into each other.35:59

If we further contract that36:01

and take the the Richie tensor.36:05

And contract over those.36:09

Remaining 2 indexes, then we get a36:12

scaler called the Richie Scaler.36:15

Um.36:21

And this from the from the36:24

symmetries of the Riemann tensor36:26

that we saw briefly last time,36:28

we can deduce that that.36:30

Richie Tensor is symmetric,36:35

so R Beta nu is equal to RU beta.36:37

By we also last time discovered that36:45

in the local and national frame.36:48

That is an explicit expression for the36:51

Richie tensor, which is in terms of36:54

derivatives of the metric. So if we.36:58

And this is not obvious if we ask what about?37:03

Peter. You knew? Comma Umbra and37:10

and differentiate the Richie tensor37:15

with respect to one of the other.37:18

Yeah, according to functions.37:24

And. Do so. Alpha beta.37:27

New Lambda or new? Ohh. Of a beta.37:31

Under you, you we discover.37:39

Or rather, Yankee discovered.37:43

That's zero, that there is a.37:46

Asymmetry of the Riemann tensor,37:51

of of the of the of the of37:53

the differential ruin tensor.37:55

So so these this is the each37:56

of these expressions is a mess37:59

of derivatives of the metric,38:01

so I think it's not too hard to38:03

work that out for yourself to to38:05

to to do the calculation yourself38:08

and discover that it is all cancel,38:10

but it's not terribly exciting.38:11

But this is being done in the.38:15

Local, natural, free.38:18

In the local inertial frame38:22

because the expression for the38:23

Riemann tensor in terms of the38:25

metric only applied in the in38:27

the in the local metal frame.38:29

In the local natural frame,38:30

however, these are.38:31

In the local natural frame38:35

covariant differentiation.38:38

Is the same as ordinary differentiation.38:39

So in that frame it turns out that we can38:41

write turn these commas in semi colon.38:46

This is a trick we did also last time.38:49

Because the in the local inertial38:52

frame the the the gammas that appear38:54

when we go the other way are all zero.38:56

But that is a tensor equation.38:59

So that although we worked39:04

out in special frame,39:05

we've worked to attentional39:06

equation in that special frame.39:07

Which means that it's not just true,39:09

it's it's it's true not just39:11

in that special frame.39:12

And and this. Expiration here is39:18

called the the Bianchi identity,39:22

and it is used for at various times39:24

in the algebra of doing the the39:26

the calculations here to to to get39:28

rid of terms, rearrange things,39:30

and make things disappear.39:32

And if we do this contraction39:35

here on the UM bank identities,39:39

we get similar one which39:42

I'll just write down South.39:44

It's on the sheet due to the new.39:45

Semi colon Lambda +3. Minus R.39:49

Beta Lambda semi colon nu plus R.39:54

Which new lambdas? And accordingly40:01

you contracted Bianchi identity.40:04

And if we can track that again.40:07

We get an expression G alpha beta40:10

semi colon beta. Equals zero.40:15

And you know I I'm missing out a40:18

lot of very boring algebra here40:20

where this could this tensor G.40:21

Is. Formed from the Richie tensor.40:26

And the metric and the Richie scaler.40:32

And this tensor here.40:36

Has this property that is that that40:39

that as a deduction of from this40:41

that is convenient derivative is 0.40:44

And that change is called40:47

the Einstein tensor.40:49

And as you might not be astonished40:50

to discover, that tends to plays40:52

quite significant part part in our40:54

in what we are about to discover.40:57

But the what?40:60

The what the the Riemann tensor? Uh.41:01

There are a lot of tensions happening here.41:07

The Riemann tensor.41:09

Is the one that we discovered contained41:11

all the information about how a vector41:14

changes as it goes around a path.41:16

So you you you plug your your question41:18

in this path that this vector go41:20

around this path you plug that that41:22

that data into the rementer and41:24

what comes out is an is information41:26

about how much that that that41:28

vector vector changes and or else41:31

you talk about the tangent to two41:33

geodesics and the link joining them.41:36

You plug those in and what comes41:38

out is information from the Riemann41:41

tensor about how much that.41:43

That, that, that,41:45

that connecting vector between these41:46

two things, how much that changes.41:48

So there's a lot of information in41:50

the Riemann tensor, the Ricci tensor.41:53

Has fewer degrees of freedom.41:56

A lot of the of stuff had been contracted41:58

away so that that there are animatrix.42:01

There are 4 by 4 components42:03

to the Richie tensor,42:04

where there are 4 by 4 by 4 by 442:05

components to the Riemann tensor.42:07

But so, but the the virtue change is,42:11

in a sense, all the bits of of information42:14

in the human density that you care about.42:16

It turns out that that that's the bit42:19

that matches most closely the stuff that42:21

is informed of to us about the curvature42:23

of the space-time going through it.42:26

And this Einstein tensor is just a adaptation42:29

of tweaked version of that Richie Tensor,42:32

which is the one with this42:35

interesting property. Which?42:38

Is of significance to us.42:42

And and having. Carefully got to the.42:48

One reason why it's important to get through42:54

this step through that section 1441.42:57

To an incremental tensor.43:01

The previous thing is that the the sort of.43:03

The the punchline of the.43:08

Of the discussion of the elementum tensor,43:13

is that the argumentum tensor?43:15

It's such that. For.43:19

So on physical grounds,43:24

based on the idea that if you have a box,43:25

the total amount of going43:28

into it must be this.43:30

Arrangement going into it must be43:32

the same as the total amount in the43:34

box minus A in the coming out of it.43:37

And a mathematical statement of43:39

that is that the? Convenient43:41

derivative of energy momentum tensor.43:44

Is 0. And the fact that the. The.43:47

This property of the.43:55

There's energy intensive43:56

describing the amount of energy,43:57

the amount of stuff in an area43:59

of space that it has this.44:02

This property here,44:05

and the fact that this potentially44:06

there's the ancient tensor which44:08

is based on the curvature of44:10

the space-time has a similar44:13

property is heavily hinting44:15

that these two things are very44:16

closely related to each other,44:18

and we'll discover that that's true.44:20

Um. OK.44:26

We'll hold on to that thought because44:31

we want to come back to that.44:34

And. I keep forgetting I've got44:36

these quick questions and then44:40

so this is scrolling past them,44:42

it's you have these slides.44:44

It's very useful to have a44:45

have a think about those quick44:47

questions in the way I suggested.44:49

In the past and doing the mental.44:53

What's my first reaction to this?44:57

Then thinking about it and going up?44:59

I I. These questions are useful not just45:03

because they remind you what's going on,45:07

because they give you a bit of45:09

a break and stop listening to45:11

me talking for an entire hour.45:13

Anyway. Um.45:15

Um.45:23

In the last couple of minutes.45:32

I'm going to just edge into.45:34

I'll start again from 2nd 4/4 to two but the.45:37

What we have now.45:45

Now we have all the materials that45:47

we can start doing physics again.45:49

Because we have some mathematical objects45:51

which have properties that are that are.45:54

And that we can attach physical meaning to.45:58

And that have a continuity conditions46:01

such as literal amount of energy,46:04

mental which conserve.46:06

That's conservation law.46:08

Which is implausible.46:09

We have something which describes curvature46:10

in a way which we think is plausible.46:13

Now we have to work out what's the46:15

relationship between those and the46:17

way we do that is by going back to46:18

the ideas that we talked about in46:21

the in part one that they brief,46:23

part one we talked about the.46:25

Things falling in lift shafts46:28

and things being freefall,46:30

and the idea of the local national46:30

frame being the one you're in46:32

when you're either away from or46:34

gravity or in free fall or lift46:36

shaft or or or something similar.46:37

And what we what we've discovered46:39

there is that you can make sense of46:41

all these things happening by talking46:44

about the equivalence principle.46:46

And I think we saw a couple one or46:47

two versions of the equivalence46:50

principle in the in part one.46:52

Which would be to do with seeing that46:54

the experience of being free fall.46:57

And the experience of being.46:60

Of not being in a gravitational field at all.47:04

Are equivalent. Not just hard to separate.47:07

Not just impossible to separate,47:10

but they are actually the same thing.47:11

And So what we're going to do next47:14

is see two further versions of the47:15

code response 2 for the statements47:16

of the equivalence principle, which.47:18

Restate that in terms that we've in47:21

slightly more sophisticated terms47:25

that we have available to us now.47:27

And also we tell us what to do next,47:29

and spoiler what it tells us is that47:31

the physics that we understand.47:35

In special relativity.47:38

Which is basically Newton's Newton physics,47:39

except with with some tweaks.47:42

So the physics we all of our our experience,47:44

the physics we understand when47:46

we jump up and down.47:48

It turns out that because of this,47:49

we can import that directly into the local47:52

inertial frame in a in a curved space-time.47:55

And because we can transform from that47:58

local natural frame to anywhere else,48:00

we at that point can use the fakes48:02

we understand in free fall and48:05

apply it in a curved space-time.48:07

And what that leased with is48:10

the problem of how do we,48:11

how precisely do we discover what48:13

the constraints are that matter48:16

applies to that space-time.48:19

In other words,48:21

how does matter change the48:22

curvature of that space-time?48:23

At which point,48:24

if we understand what the space-time is,48:25

what the what the shape of the space-time is,48:27

and kind of work out,48:30

and we haven't done this yet,48:31

you can work out how things will48:32

move through that space-time.48:34

Spoiler is logistics.48:35

Then we have walked out how things48:37

move in a curved space-time and48:39

we have reached our goal.48:41

So there's only a couple more steps to do,48:43

and each of those steps is in a48:45

way quite short, quite, quite,48:46

quite, quite small step at this48:48

point because of all the work we've48:50

done about understanding duties,48:52

understanding curvature and48:54

understanding the metric.48:55

So this is where it all comes48:57

together to get Einstein's equations,48:59

which are the instance,49:00

the end point of who we are.49:01

So the next time I aim to get to the49:03

point where at least we're at two49:06

and beyond the point where we are49:08

talking about some equations and we49:09

got onto one simple solution and all of G2.49:11

Solutions to integrate.49:13